{"prompt":"You are comparing an AI-suggested code fix with actual changes made in a commit.\n\nYour task: Determine if the commit contains the essence of the AI fix and provide a confidence level.\n\n## AI-Suggested Fix\n\n**What it fixes:** :gradle-project-graph:gradle:ktfmtCheckTest\n\n**Description:** chore(gradle): fix ktfmt formatting in AddTestCiTargetsTest\n\n**Reasoning:** The PR introduced changes to AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt that modified the test assertions to check for object-based dependsOn entries instead of string-based entries. When these changes were made, the assertTrue call at line 166 was formatted across multiple lines, which violated the ktfmt formatting rules for this project.\n\nThe ktfmt formatter determined that the assertion statement was short enough to fit on a single line (under the line length limit) and should therefore be collapsed into a sing\n\n**Suggested Changes (diff):**\n```diff\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\nindex fa9b01a5a5..ce602297d4 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\n@@ -163,9 +163,7 @@ class AddTestCiTargetsTest {\n // Same-project dependencies are not included in dependsOn;\n // Gradle handles same-project task ordering internally.\n val dependsOn = ciTarget?.get(\"dependsOn\")\n- assertTrue(\n- dependsOn == null,\n- \"Same-project dependsOn should not be present, got $dependsOn\")\n+ assertTrue(dependsOn == null, \"Same-project dependsOn should not be present, got $dependsOn\")\n }\n \n @Test\n\n```\n\n## Actual Commit Changes\n\n**Commit Diff:**\n```diff\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProjectUtils.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProjectUtils.kt\nindex 9af79d4cd911fd..5e07d70be30996 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProjectUtils.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProjectUtils.kt\n@@ -207,18 +207,34 @@ fun processTargetsForProject(\n val ciCheckTargetName =\n applyPrefix(targetNameOverrides.getOrDefault(\"ciCheckTargetName\", \"check-ci\"))\n if (task.name == \"check\") {\n- @Suppress(\"UNCHECKED_CAST\")\n- val replacedDependencies =\n- (target[\"dependsOn\"] as? List>)?.map { dependency ->\n- val depTarget = dependency[\"target\"] as? String ?: return@map dependency\n-\n+ // Get all dependencies (same-project + cross-project) directly from\n+ // Gradle's task graph for CI target construction.\n+ // The target's dependsOn only has cross-project deps (same-project\n+ // deps are handled by Gradle internally), but CI targets need to\n+ // reference same-project targets like test -> test-ci.\n+ val allCheckDeps = getDependsOnTask(task)\n+ val ciCheckDependsOn = mutableListOf>()\n+\n+ allCheckDeps.forEach { depTask ->\n+ val depProject = depTask.project\n+ if (depProject.buildFile.path != null && depProject.buildFile.exists()) {\n+ val depTargetName =\n+ applyPrefix(\n+ if (depTask.name == \"test\" &&\n+ targetNameOverrides.containsKey(\"testTargetName\")) {\n+ targetNameOverrides[\"testTargetName\"]!!\n+ } else {\n+ depTask.name\n+ })\n+\n+ if (depProject == project) {\n+ // Same-project dep: replace test targets with CI test targets\n val newTargetName =\n when {\n- hasCiTestTarget && depTarget == testTargetName -> ciTestTargetBaseName\n+ hasCiTestTarget && depTargetName == testTargetName -> ciTestTargetBaseName\n hasCiTestTarget -> {\n- // depTarget is already prefixed, so use pre-indexed lookup\n- val matchingTask = testTasksByPrefixedName[depTarget]\n- if (matchingTask != null && depTarget != testTargetName) {\n+ val matchingTask = testTasksByPrefixedName[depTargetName]\n+ if (matchingTask != null && depTargetName != testTargetName) {\n \"$ciTestTargetBaseName-${matchingTask.name}\"\n } else {\n null\n@@ -226,17 +242,20 @@ fun processTargetsForProject(\n }\n else -> null\n }\n-\n- if (newTargetName != null) {\n- dependency.toMutableMap().apply { this[\"target\"] = newTargetName }\n- } else {\n- dependency\n- }\n- } ?: emptyList()\n+ ciCheckDependsOn.add(mapOf(\"target\" to (newTargetName ?: depTargetName)))\n+ } else {\n+ // Cross-project dep: keep as-is\n+ ciCheckDependsOn.add(\n+ mapOf(\n+ \"target\" to depTargetName,\n+ \"projects\" to listOf(getNxProjectName(depProject))))\n+ }\n+ }\n+ }\n \n val newTarget: MutableMap =\n mutableMapOf(\n- \"dependsOn\" to replacedDependencies,\n+ \"dependsOn\" to ciCheckDependsOn,\n \"executor\" to \"nx:noop\",\n \"cache\" to true,\n \"metadata\" to getMetadata(\"Runs Gradle Check in CI\", projectBuildPath, \"check\"))\n@@ -249,20 +268,40 @@ fun processTargetsForProject(\n if (task.name == \"build\") {\n val ciBuildTargetName =\n applyPrefix(targetNameOverrides.getOrDefault(\"ciBuildTargetName\", \"build-ci\"))\n- @Suppress(\"UNCHECKED_CAST\")\n- val replacedDependencies =\n- (target[\"dependsOn\"] as? List>)?.map { dep ->\n- val depTarget = dep[\"target\"] as? String ?: return@map dep\n- if (depTarget == applyPrefix(\"check\")) {\n- dep.toMutableMap().apply { this[\"target\"] = ciCheckTargetName }\n- } else {\n- dep\n- }\n- } ?: emptyList()\n+ // Get all dependencies directly from Gradle's task graph\n+ val allBuildDeps = getDependsOnTask(task)\n+ val ciBuildDependsOn = mutableListOf>()\n+\n+ allBuildDeps.forEach { depTask ->\n+ val depProject = depTask.project\n+ if (depProject.buildFile.path != null && depProject.buildFile.exists()) {\n+ val depTargetName =\n+ applyPrefix(\n+ if (depTask.name == \"test\" &&\n+ targetNameOverrides.containsKey(\"testTargetName\")) {\n+ targetNameOverrides[\"testTargetName\"]!!\n+ } else {\n+ depTask.name\n+ })\n+\n+ if (depProject == project) {\n+ // Same-project dep: replace check with check-ci\n+ val finalTargetName =\n+ if (depTargetName == applyPrefix(\"check\")) ciCheckTargetName else depTargetName\n+ ciBuildDependsOn.add(mapOf(\"target\" to finalTargetName))\n+ } else {\n+ // Cross-project dep: keep as-is\n+ ciBuildDependsOn.add(\n+ mapOf(\n+ \"target\" to depTargetName,\n+ \"projects\" to listOf(getNxProjectName(depProject))))\n+ }\n+ }\n+ }\n \n val newTarget: MutableMap =\n mutableMapOf(\n- \"dependsOn\" to replacedDependencies,\n+ \"dependsOn\" to ciBuildDependsOn,\n \"executor\" to \"nx:noop\",\n \"cache\" to true,\n \"metadata\" to getMetadata(\"Runs Gradle Build in CI\", projectBuildPath, \"build\"))\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/TaskUtils.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/TaskUtils.kt\nindex ed47009af209dc..45d0477d1f738c 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/TaskUtils.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/main/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/TaskUtils.kt\n@@ -340,11 +340,10 @@ fun getDependsOnForTask(\n val result = mutableListOf>()\n val grouped = depEntries.groupBy { it.isSameProject }\n \n- // Same-project dependencies: one entry per target\n- grouped[true]\n- ?.map { it.targetName }\n- ?.distinct()\n- ?.forEach { targetName -> result.add(mapOf(\"target\" to targetName)) }\n+ // Same-project dependencies are NOT included in dependsOn.\n+ // Gradle handles same-project task ordering internally when running a task.\n+ // Including them would cause Nx to schedule them as separate tasks, which\n+ // can fail when tasks exist during project graph generation but not execution.\n \n // Cross-project dependencies: group by target, collect projects into array\n grouped[false]\n@@ -366,7 +365,7 @@ fun getDependsOnForTask(\n val combinedDependsOn = getDependsOnTask(task)\n val result =\n if (combinedDependsOn.isNotEmpty()) {\n- mapTasksToObjects(combinedDependsOn)\n+ mapTasksToObjects(combinedDependsOn).ifEmpty { null }\n } else {\n null\n }\n@@ -388,7 +387,7 @@ fun getDependsOnForTask(\n return try {\n val result =\n if (dependsOnTasks.isNotEmpty()) {\n- mapTasksToObjects(dependsOnTasks)\n+ mapTasksToObjects(dependsOnTasks).ifEmpty { null }\n } else {\n null\n }\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\nindex 69a630123c0526..fa9b01a5a52ec4 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt\n@@ -126,7 +126,7 @@ class AddTestCiTargetsTest {\n }\n \n @Test\n- fun `should include dependsOn when test task has dependencies`() {\n+ fun `should not include same-project dependsOn for CI targets`() {\n File(projectRoot, \"build.gradle\").apply { writeText(\"// test build file\") }\n \n val testFile =\n@@ -160,13 +160,12 @@ class AddTestCiTargetsTest {\n val ciTarget = targets[\"ci--DependentTest\"]\n assertTrue(ciTarget != null, \"CI target should be created\")\n \n- @Suppress(\"UNCHECKED_CAST\")\n- val dependsOn = ciTarget?.get(\"dependsOn\") as? List>\n- assertTrue(dependsOn != null, \"dependsOn should be present when test task has dependencies\")\n- assertTrue(dependsOn!!.isNotEmpty(), \"dependsOn should not be empty\")\n+ // Same-project dependencies are not included in dependsOn;\n+ // Gradle handles same-project task ordering internally.\n+ val dependsOn = ciTarget?.get(\"dependsOn\")\n assertTrue(\n- dependsOn.any { it[\"target\"] == \"compileTestKotlin\" },\n- \"dependsOn should contain the dependency task name\")\n+ dependsOn == null,\n+ \"Same-project dependsOn should not be present, got $dependsOn\")\n }\n \n @Test\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTargetsForProjectTest.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTargetsForProjectTest.kt\nindex 6e6ec3da47d2fa..44517c90bf299a 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTargetsForProjectTest.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTargetsForProjectTest.kt\n@@ -81,15 +81,13 @@ class ProcessTargetsForProjectTest {\n gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-build\"],\n \"Expected ci-build target to be present in processed targets\")\n \n- // Verify dependencies are rewritten for 'check' and 'build' tasks in the returned targets\n+ // Same-project dependsOn are not included in regular targets (Gradle handles internally)\n val checkTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"check\"]\n assertNotNull(checkTarget, \"Check target should exist in processed targets\")\n- val checkDependsOn = checkTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n- assertNotNull(checkDependsOn, \"Check dependsOn should not be null in processed targets\")\n- assertTrue(\n- checkDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"test\" },\n- \"Expected 'check' to depend on 'test' in processed targets, got $checkDependsOn\")\n+ val buildTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"build\"]\n+ assertNotNull(buildTarget, \"Build target should exist in processed targets\")\n \n+ // CI targets compute dependencies directly from Gradle's task graph\n val checkCiTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-check\"]\n assertNotNull(checkCiTarget, \"Check CI target should exist in processed targets\")\n val checkCiDependsOn = checkCiTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n@@ -98,14 +96,6 @@ class ProcessTargetsForProjectTest {\n checkCiDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"ci-test\" },\n \"Expected 'ci-check' to depend on 'ci-test' in processed targets, got $checkCiDependsOn\")\n \n- val buildTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"build\"]\n- assertNotNull(buildTarget, \"Build target should exist in processed targets\")\n- val buildDependsOn = buildTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n- assertNotNull(buildDependsOn, \"Build dependsOn should not be null in processed targets\")\n- assertTrue(\n- buildDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"check\" },\n- \"Expected 'build' to depend on 'check' in processed targets, got $buildDependsOn\")\n-\n val buildCiTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-build\"]\n assertNotNull(buildCiTarget, \"Build CI target should exist in processed targets\")\n val buildCiDependsOn = buildCiTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n@@ -198,22 +188,18 @@ class ProcessTargetsForProjectTest {\n gradleTargets.targets.containsKey(\"ci-build\"),\n \"Expected ci-build target to be present as a main target\")\n \n- // Verify dependencies are NOT rewritten for 'check' and 'build' tasks\n+ // Same-project dependsOn are not included in regular targets (Gradle handles internally)\n val checkTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"check\"]\n assertNotNull(checkTarget, \"Check target should exist\")\n- val checkDependsOn = checkTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n- assertNotNull(checkDependsOn, \"Check dependsOn should not be null\")\n- assertTrue(\n- checkDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"test\" },\n- \"Expected 'check' to depend on 'test', got $checkDependsOn\")\n- assertFalse(\n- checkDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"ci-test\" },\n- \"Expected 'check' NOT to depend on 'ci-test'\")\n+ val buildTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"build\"]\n+ assertNotNull(buildTarget, \"Build target should exist\")\n \n+ // CI targets compute dependencies directly from Gradle's task graph\n val checkCiTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-check\"]\n assertNotNull(checkCiTarget, \"Check CI target should exist in processed targets\")\n val checkCiDependsOn = checkCiTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n assertNotNull(checkCiDependsOn, \"Check CI dependsOn should not be null in processed targets\")\n+ // When atomized is false, ci-check should depend on 'test' (not 'ci-test')\n assertFalse(\n checkCiDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"ci-test\" },\n \"Expected 'ci-check' to NOT depend on 'ci-test' in processed targets\")\n@@ -221,17 +207,6 @@ class ProcessTargetsForProjectTest {\n checkCiDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"test\" },\n \"Expected 'ci-check' to depend on 'test' in processed targets, got $checkCiDependsOn\")\n \n- val buildTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"build\"]\n- assertNotNull(buildTarget, \"Build target should exist\")\n- val buildDependsOn = buildTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n- assertNotNull(buildDependsOn, \"Build dependsOn should not be null\")\n- assertTrue(\n- buildDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"check\" },\n- \"Expected 'build' to depend on 'check', got $buildDependsOn\")\n- assertFalse(\n- buildDependsOn.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"ci-check\" },\n- \"Expected 'build' NOT to depend on 'ci-check'\")\n-\n val buildCiTarget = gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-build\"]\n assertNotNull(buildCiTarget, \"Build CI target should exist in processed targets\")\n val buildCiDependsOn = buildCiTarget[\"dependsOn\"] as? List<*>\n@@ -420,11 +395,8 @@ class ProcessTargetsForProjectTest {\n workspaceRoot = workspaceRoot,\n atomized = true)\n \n- val checkDependsOn = gradleTargets.targets[\"check\"]?.get(\"dependsOn\") as? List<*>\n- assertTrue(\n- checkDependsOn?.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"test\" } == true,\n- \"Expected check to depend on 'test', got $checkDependsOn\")\n-\n+ // Same-project dependsOn are not included in regular targets\n+ // CI targets compute dependencies directly from Gradle's task graph\n val ciCheckDependsOn = gradleTargets.targets[\"ci-check\"]?.get(\"dependsOn\") as? List<*>\n assertTrue(\n ciCheckDependsOn?.any { (it as? Map<*, *>)?.get(\"target\") == \"ci-test\" } == true,\ndiff --git a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTaskUtilsTest.kt b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTaskUtilsTest.kt\nindex cadeb913d092b5..0a7b9ebda9c21f 100644\n--- a/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTaskUtilsTest.kt\n+++ b/packages/gradle/project-graph/src/test/kotlin/dev/nx/gradle/utils/ProcessTaskUtilsTest.kt\n@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ class ProcessTaskUtilsTest {\n }\n \n @Test\n- fun `test getDependsOnForTask with direct dependsOn`() {\n+ fun `test getDependsOnForTask with direct dependsOn same project returns null`() {\n val project = ProjectBuilder.builder().withName(\"myApp\").build()\n // Create a build file so the task dependencies are properly detected\n val buildFile = java.io.File(project.projectDir, \"build.gradle\")\n@@ -81,10 +81,9 @@ class ProcessTaskUtilsTest {\n val dependencies = mutableSetOf()\n val dependsOn = getDependsOnForTask(null, taskA, dependencies)\n \n- assertNotNull(dependsOn)\n- assertTrue(\n- dependsOn!!.any { it[\"target\"] == \"taskB\" },\n- \"Expected dependsOn entry with target 'taskB' but got $dependsOn\")\n+ // Same-project dependencies are not included in dependsOn;\n+ // Gradle handles same-project task ordering internally.\n+ assertNull(dependsOn)\n }\n \n @Test\n@@ -246,7 +245,7 @@ class ProcessTaskUtilsTest {\n }\n \n @Test\n- fun `test getDependsOnForTask with pre-computed dependsOnTasks`() {\n+ fun `test getDependsOnForTask with pre-computed dependsOnTasks same project returns null`() {\n // Create a build file so the task dependencies are properly detected\n val buildFile = java.io.File(project.projectDir, \"build.gradle\")\n buildFile.writeText(\"// test build file\")\n@@ -269,25 +268,10 @@ class ProcessTaskUtilsTest {\n val dependencies2 = mutableSetOf()\n val resultWithoutPreComputed = getDependsOnForTask(null, taskA, dependencies2)\n \n- // Both results should be identical\n- assertNotNull(resultWithPreComputed)\n- assertNotNull(resultWithoutPreComputed)\n- assertEquals(resultWithPreComputed!!.size, resultWithoutPreComputed!!.size)\n- assertEquals(2, resultWithPreComputed.size)\n-\n- // Should contain both dependencies as object entries with target names\n- assertTrue(\n- resultWithPreComputed.any { it[\"target\"] == \"taskB\" },\n- \"Expected target 'taskB' in $resultWithPreComputed\")\n- assertTrue(\n- resultWithPreComputed.any { it[\"target\"] == \"taskC\" },\n- \"Expected target 'taskC' in $resultWithPreComputed\")\n- assertTrue(\n- resultWithoutPreComputed.any { it[\"target\"] == \"taskB\" },\n- \"Expected target 'taskB' in $resultWithoutPreComputed\")\n- assertTrue(\n- resultWithoutPreComputed.any { it[\"target\"] == \"taskC\" },\n- \"Expected target 'taskC' in $resultWithoutPreComputed\")\n+ // Same-project dependencies are not included in dependsOn;\n+ // Gradle handles same-project task ordering internally.\n+ assertNull(resultWithPreComputed)\n+ assertNull(resultWithoutPreComputed)\n }\n \n @Test\n@@ -488,11 +472,8 @@ class ProcessTaskUtilsTest {\n assertNotNull(result[\"metadata\"])\n assertNotNull(result[\"options\"])\n \n- // Verify dependsOn is populated with object format\n- @Suppress(\"UNCHECKED_CAST\") val dependsOn = result[\"dependsOn\"] as? List>\n- assertNotNull(dependsOn)\n- assertEquals(1, dependsOn!!.size)\n- assertEquals(\"compile\", dependsOn[0][\"target\"])\n+ // Same-project dependsOn should not be included (Gradle handles internally)\n+ assertNull(result[\"dependsOn\"])\n \n // Verify inputs contain both regular inputs and consolidated dependentTasksOutputFiles\n val inputs = result[\"inputs\"] as? List<*>\n\n```\n\n## Instructions\n\nRate how similar the commit is to the AI fix on a scale of 0-10.\n\n**Scoring Guide:**\n- 10: Nearly identical changes (same files, same logic, same fixes)\n- 8-9: Very similar (same core changes, minor differences in implementation)\n- 6-7: Similar intent (addresses same issue, somewhat different approach)\n- 4-5: Some overlap (touches same area, but different changes)\n- 2-3: Minimal similarity (different files or completely different changes)\n- 0-1: No similarity (unrelated changes)\n\n**Criteria:**\n- Focus on: same files modified, similar logic changes, same bug being fixed\n- The commit may have additional changes beyond the AI fix - that's okay\n- Small differences in implementation are okay if the intent is the same\n\nProvide your score (0-10) and a brief reasoning (2-3 sentences) explaining your assessment.","response":"{\"score\":6,\"reasoning\":\"The AI-suggested fix targets a specific ktfmt formatting issue in AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt at line 166, collapsing a multi-line assertTrue statement into a single line. The actual commit does include this exact change in AddTestCiTargetsTest.kt (lines 166-168 in the diff), but it is embedded within a much larger refactoring that modifies ProjectUtils.kt, TaskUtils.kt, and multiple test files. The core formatting fix is present and correct, but the commit represents a substantially broader set of changes addressing dependency handling logic rather than just the ktfmt formatting issue.\"}","model":"claude-haiku-4-5-20251001","cipeFixId":"69aa0efb3e4626f15e452708","headSha":"3aff1d4d71f0b309162a272163990cad4c3e2580","timestamp":1772765809620}